Data Integrity and Computer System Validation (ALCOA+, GAMP 5, Part 11)
Data integrity is still where inspections go first
When records cannot be trusted, the rest of the quality system is hard to defend. Data integrity problems show up in batch records, laboratory systems, audit trails, spreadsheets, and hybrid paper-electronic processes. Regulators expect evidence that data are attributable, legible, contemporaneous, original, and accurate, and that those ALCOA+ expectations extend through complete, consistent, enduring, and available records.
GxP Auditing and Consulting Services provides data integrity and computer system validation (CSV) support led by Ramzi W. Kozal, CQA, an independent GxP lead auditor with nearly 30 years of experience. The work covers ALCOA+ assessments, audit trail reviews, 21 CFR Part 11 evaluations, and validation planning for computerized systems in regulated operations, using a GAMP 5-aligned approach.
This is not a software-engineering staff-augmentation service. It is audit and consulting support for the integrity of GxP data and the validated state of the systems that hold them.
ALCOA+ in an operating quality system
An ALCOA+ review looks at how data are actually created, changed, reviewed, and retained, not only at whether a policy says the right words. Typical questions include whether users share logins, whether audit trails are enabled and reviewed, whether original electronic records can be reconstructed, whether paper printouts are treated as the record when they are not, and whether backup, retention, and access controls keep records complete and available.
These issues appear in pharmaceutical GMP operations under 21 CFR Parts 210 and 211, in radiopharmaceutical operations under 21 CFR Part 212, in dietary supplement cGMP under 21 CFR Part 111, and in GCP and GLP settings where trial or laboratory data must remain reliable. The assessment is tailored to the process and the system, not copied from a generic checklist.
Findings are ranked so the organization can separate issues that undermine the trustworthiness of product or quality decisions from documentation weaknesses that still need to be fixed but are not the first inspection risk.
Computer system validation and GAMP 5
Computer system validation is how you show that a GxP system is fit for its intended use and stays in a state of control. A GAMP 5-aligned approach starts with intended use and risk, then determines how much specification, testing, and ongoing control the system actually needs. That is more useful than applying the same validation package to every tool.
Support can include validation planning, 21 CFR Part 11 and data integrity assessments, reviews of existing validation packages, and planning for systems such as LIMS, ERP, or electronic batch records. It can also include gap assessments of legacy systems that were never validated to current expectations, or that drifted after change.
The intended result is a realistic validation and control plan: enough rigor for the risk, documented in a way that an inspector can follow.
21 CFR Part 11, in context
21 CFR Part 11 applies to electronic records and electronic signatures used to meet FDA requirements. A Part 11 assessment looks at whether the system and the surrounding procedures actually support identification, signature meaning, record security, audit trails, and operational controls. It is not a sticker that can be placed on software after a vendor says “Part 11 ready.”
Part 11 questions are often mixed with ALCOA+ and CSV questions, which is why this practice treats them as one service rather than three disconnected reports. If a system cannot protect the record, validation paperwork will not save it. If the system is validated but the process around it allows shared passwords or disabled audit trails, the inspection risk remains.
How an assessment is approached
Work begins by identifying the records, systems, and processes in scope: for example, a QC LIMS, an electronic batch record, a document management system, or a set of spreadsheets used in GxP decisions. The review then samples configuration, access, audit trails, validation evidence, SOPs, and actual user practice.
Assessments may be remote (worldwide) or on site (US and international). You receive a written report of gaps, risk-ranked findings, and recommended remediation or validation next steps. If the same issues sit inside a broader QMS problem, work can continue through quality system remediation, including support in Veeva Vault or TrackWise. If the findings belong in a mock inspection or a vendor audit, those services can be combined.
To request a data integrity, ALCOA+, Part 11, or CSV assessment, contact GxP Auditing and Consulting Services or call (239) 207-8132. A consultation will define the systems in scope and whether a narrow review or a wider inspection-readiness exercise is the better starting point.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a data integrity audit and CSV work?
A data integrity audit examines whether GxP records meet ALCOA+ expectations in practice, including audit trails, access, and record retention. CSV work examines whether the computerized system is validated and controlled for its intended use, often using a GAMP 5-aligned approach. Many assessments include both, because weak validation and weak data practices usually appear together.
Do you validate systems for us from scratch?
The practice provides CSV and data integrity consulting, including validation planning, Part 11 assessments, audit trail reviews, and reviews of electronic batch record or LIMS/ERP validation plans. It is audit-and-consulting support, not an outsourced software development team.
Which regulations do these assessments use?
Data integrity and electronic record reviews commonly use ALCOA+ expectations, 21 CFR Part 11, and the GxP rules that apply to the operation, such as 21 CFR 210/211, 212, 111, or GCP/GLP requirements.
Can you review a system that is already in use?
Yes. Legacy or previously deployed systems are often the ones that need a gap assessment, a retrospective review, or a plan to restore a validated and inspection-ready state.
Will this help with inspection readiness?
Yes. Data integrity and computerized-system issues are frequent inspection topics. Findings from this work can feed a mock FDA or EMA inspection, a CAPA plan, or a broader QMS remediation effort.
_edited.png)